I plan to investigate this thorny question in detail, but not for another 6-9 months. I'll explain the reason for the delay later. However, I thought you'd like to see an early analysis. But first some background.
The answer under V3?
In
2018
and
2020
I used the Art de la Guerre (ADLG) results database to probe the perennial
question of super armies. In
early 2021 I used the
same data to look at the performance of the Yuan Chinese following their
success at the World Championships from 2016 to 2019.
The above chart shows that the more an army is used, the more its performance (efficacy in ADLG-speak) tends towards 50%. So in short, the answer is no: there aren't any super armies in ADLG. Remember, by super armies I mean armies that will have a high degree of success regardless of who is using it.



